Much like my barely legible high school handwriting has deteriorated across a quarter-century of digital document creation, my instincts to halt and record progress in a game waned. I blame the advent of automatic saving, checkpoints, Xbox Quick Resume, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I instinctively save constantly in case things blow up. But I’m not perfect. I become complacent. Recently, I learned a vital reminder after significant time invested in the fresh Switch version of Pokémon FireRed on the Switch: you still gotta manually hit save.
Many years had gone by since I picked up a pixel-art Pokémon adventure — as I skipped the GBA era, the Generation II titles probably were the last mainline Poké-title I completed. Consequently, I was thrilled to pay twenty dollars for a trip down memory lane back to Kanto, and an attempt to catch those classic 151 pocket monsters. I was instantly transported to my youth. During a handful of gaming sessions, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, added Pikachu to my team, knocked out Brock with ease, gambled on buying the Magikarp from a shady character, and scaled Mt. Moon without a worry in the world.
The fatal flaw: Not once did I save! And never thought to.
Alas, Jigglypuff can never be friends with my Mankey.
Disaster struck on a night while I was taking a break from the game… and as my daughter picked up the Switch for a brief session of the latest game in its place, quitting my application as a result. As any Switch user understands (a fact I foolishly ignored…) opening a new game on the system forces the closure of any software running. Your data is only preserved if the game autosaved or you saved manually prior to changing games. Oops.
The Evolution of Game Saves: From Intentional to Invisible
It's fair to consider autosave, now so invisible most players barely notice it, as a true “cutting-edge” advancement. Whereas the early computer game Zork featured among the first save systems in gaming, the 1986 Zelda title is widely hailed as a pivotal point for alleviating the sensation of being utterly defeated by an in-game fail due to cartridge-based saving on the classic console. Of course, you still had to remember to save. (And after one flub), it was a mistake made only once. During the nineties, external memory cards like PlayStation made saving more common yet still fragile; failing to save (or having a card corrupt) meant losing significant playtime. The survival horror series Resident Evil took it further by transforming saving into a limited resource.
Modern autosave, which suppressed my instinct to save my FireRed run so effectively, took hold at the dawn of a new century. The first Halo pioneered seamless respawn points whereas later franchises like Call of Duty refined the system to ease frustration and reduce tedious replay. As experiences became more vast — and increasingly non-linear — developers solved the puzzle of persistent, invisible saving and, in time, the pinnacle of instant on/off.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Curiously, the world of Pokémon offers a clear snapshot of that historical progression. For decades, preserving your Pokédex progress was manual: gamers were conditioned to select the Save option prior to shutting off their device. The shift began with Pokémon Sword and Shield on the hybrid console, Game Freak implemented autosave (at first as a toggleable option), marking a major attitude adjustment for a franchise known as staunchest upholders of tradition.
I can admit failure: Years of playing Breath of the Wild and contemporary Nintendo titles utterly weakened my instinct to save. I still know better with certain games — I wouldn't dare risk exiting prematurely in something like Hades 2 even knowing it autosaves after chambers — however, perhaps due to my extended absence from into a retro-style game, or I’ve just been spoiled, it didn’t even occur to me to preserve my progress before redocking. Seven-year-old me would not have made such a mistake this badly.
The Result: Starting From Scratch
I have not opened FireRed following the great progress wipe. When I loaded it back up to find just a lone Squirtle on my roster, my motivation evaporated. My personal status: Burned.
Maybe I’ll go back… or maybe I’ll stick with the ocean of contemporary releases available now that kindly assume I am incapable of manual saving. However, my love for retro gaming persists. During times I can distract my daughter away from the modern, auto-saving Pokémon game, we have been cooperatively playing some retro multiplayer mayhem. Those classic titles skipped saving altogether in favor of cryptic character strings. Therefore, if I blow myself up, the setback is minimal. For now, that’s comfort.